Banner Contest Voting

[MaXtreme]

New Voting click here http://cardfight-wiki.ru/areafor/index.php/topic,1029.msg11724.html#msg11724

This topic will only be used for voting, other replies will be erased. Vote here for every banner in a scale of 1 to 10 and if you wish you may add the reason you voted for such number. And even if you know who did it do not reveal the identity of the author

This voting will apply from the moment of this post to tuesday 23:00 London time. Since wednesday the voting will be a little different.

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

[Koji]

First one:

Spoiler

I have to say, this is probably the best banner out of all the 4. 10/10 from me o3o. It's just so well made, the colors are amazing and the way Blaster Blade Spirit is put in there is awesome. Deserves to be the winner, good job to whoever made it

Second one:

Spoiler

Just not that good, it looks sloppy, like barely any effort was put into it :c 3/10

Third one:

Spoiler

I'd say it's average, but has potential. the pictures don't look so well together, as much as I want this one to win because it has LJ in it and is better than the 2nd one, it could've been better in my opinion. 6/10

Fourth one:

Spoiler

I'd say this is too close. 10/10 o3o. This banner is as amazing as the first one. It also deserves to be the winner.. but I'm torn between the two o3o.

[PrinceBirth]

First Artist Score
10/10

Who ever made this one, did a very good job. I think it deserves to win. I like the colors and how everything is put together, and blended. I give my credits to the artist. A beautiful banner, that seems like it took a lot of work.  

Second Artist Score
1/10

I'm sorry for the score. I really appreciate you taking the time to make a banner for everyone on Cardfight Area. It just looks like you didnt put any effort in making this. It just looks like a bunch of random pictures put together. sorry 

Third Artist Score
2/10

Sorry It looks like this one was made by the same artist as the second one. I just think you need to put more effort into it. 

Fourth Artist Score
10/10

Very Nice! I also think yours deserves to win. I think the colors are blended well, the little effects you put in are great, and it seems like you put alot of effort into. You did a amazing job. A beautiful banner. 

[Meruem]

First Banner: 10/10
It looks excellent, gives a some kind of "mature" and serious air to the forum, for me it's the best of the 4

Second banner: 1/10
looks very messy (no offense intended) it's like you put a lot of random pics together and that's it, sorry!

Third banner: 2/10
Like the second banner, looks messy even though u at least placed the images in a certain order, looks more like a hype for the new cards rather than a banner for the forum.

fourth banner: 9/10
very well done! the background is nice, my only problem with the banner is that it looks childish

[Lance Korilum]

1. 10/10

2. 1/10

3. 1/10

4. 5/10

[Tsurugi kyousuki]

1. 9/10
2.1/10
3.1/10
4.10/10

[[ER] Patrickzzz]

1. 10/10
2.4/10
3.6/10
4.9/10(Should be a 10 but im gonna put a 9 because im a little more inclined to the number 1)

[Beryl]

1) 10/10
2) 2/10
3) 4/10
4) 9/10

[ヤタ]

1. 10/10 Yes. Yes. Yes. Actual effects, good shit.
2. 1/10 Just.... no.
3. 3/10 It's sloppy. Needs large improvement.
4. 9/10 I love this one omg yessss

EDIT: Screw that top is best.

[MaXtreme]

About 13 hours left, here's the score so far:

#1: 79 points
#2: 14 points
#3: 25 points
#4: 71 points

[Pisces]

1) 10
2) 0
3) 1
4) 9.5 (if needs to be a whole number, make it 10)

@2&3: I personally would like to have seen more effort put into the banners you both submitted. @3: You put a little more effort than 2 by putting the logo. thank you.

[Magus TSS]

Spoiler

Well Let's see.

First one is amazing. The art makes it work so perfectly. It's just my one little gripe with it is that the words feel bland. I really think that more effort could have been done to improve that. I kinda wished it had matched the Cardfight Vanguard logo text a little. It gets a 9/10.

Both the second one and third one look really terrible. All that was done was pictures was added to a background. The second one text doesn't work at all.
The third one is a tiny bit better text wise but it looks just as bad due to it not looking like it's in one picture.

The second one gets a 1/10
The Third one gets a 2/10

This last one is the one I like the best by far. There is so much more to look at and enjoy and it's inviting me to want to be here. I prefer the text one this one over the first one as well. It gets a 10/10.

Both the first one and the last one had the most effort put into them. So I give them both props for being so good and I hope one of those 2 wins.

[{GOD}Soul]

Spoiler

Short and simple first one is very blended together looks like time was definitely put into it 10/10
Second one is just collage 4/10
Third one is okay not bad but to similar to the second one so erks me 7/10
Fourth one is nice and cool not bad looking at all but the first one slightly is better so 9/10

[MaXtreme]

Voting #1 done, now to reveal the order

#1 place Banner made by Volk (108 Points)
#2 place Banner made by Hibiki (99.5 Points)
#3 place Banner made from Tohka Yatogami (35 Points)
#4 place Banner also form Tohka Yatogami (18 Points) (this is what happens when you add LJ images people)


Volk send me your IGN and the 2 sleeves you wish to win (note: you need to send the name of the sleeve and which number that you can find on the sprite folder of the game)



Now for the vote #2 that will take action for 48 hours from the time this post is released

You can all see the winner Volk's banner below:




It was planned to this winner to take over our current banner, but due to popular demand i'll give people a choice. You have 2 choices:

#1 Replace the Banner;
#2 Keep the current one.


Reply in this same thread which option you'd select, but this time you must give a reason. (yes i might have done a contest only to give sleeves probably)

[Magus TSS]

Well this is such a hard choice because both banners are extremely good in their own right. I prefer the original banner because it's more colorful and has more meaning. But the problem that meaning only last until the current season of vanguard is concluded. However the current banner can represent a universal standpoint on how vanguard is. Though it's not as colorful.

What was most important that ultimately helped me decide was does it show me what cardfighting itself is all about?
In the end that's what ended up having me pick this final choice.

My Vote is:

Spoiler

To Replace the Banner with the winning one. I was originally against the idea of the banner being changed. I was afraid that the banner would not show what vanguard is however Volk gave us a nice showing of what vanguard truly is in one beautiful banner.