Legion Creation Contest [Voting]

[Ryukkun]

Ok but people participating can vote? Self-votes doesn't count right?

As long as it'd be (total of points the artwork got-(the maker's vote))/(10x(number of ratings the artwork got-1)), i guess it's fine. but say if it accidentally becomes  (total of points the artwork got-(the maker's vote))/(10x(number of ratings the artwork got)), it'd be unfair for the maker since that'd put him at a 1 vote disadvantage. Also, I think it's pretty stupid for one to overly rate his own work for unjustified reasons, unless they're too desperate to win a sleeve >.>. In the end, I'm just stating my say on participants' voting for their own work.

[Rank Up]

Hey there, here is top 10 legion by this time (I will update as new votes will be posted):

I) #9 (102)
II) #13 (92.5)
III) #12 (92)
IV) #30 and #33 (91)
V) -
VI)  #23 (89)
VII) #25 (88)
VIII) #26 (81)
IX) #6 (80)
X) #24 (79)

All scores

1) (53)
2) (40)
3) (54)
4) (43)
5) (45)
6) (80)
7) (65.5)
(39)
9) (102)
10) (77.5)
11) (50)
12) (92)
13) (92.5)
14) (81)
15) (69.5)
16) (62.5)
17) (49.5)
18) (71)
19) (68)
20) (54.5)
21) (75)
22) (72)
23) (89)
24) (79)
25) (88)
26) (81)
27) (40)
28) (76)
29) (29+?)
30) (91+?)
31) (28+?)
32) (71+?)
33) (91+?)
34) (58+?)
35) (69+?)
36) (26+?)

"?" means there should be more points, but someone didnt voted this legion yet, while voting others.

Russian forum - last vote was from Din; English forum - last vote was from Hideyoshi.

P.S Hideyoshi, pls vote 29th legion. Magus TSS we are w8ing for you to end your post

[Lunaze]

I forget so send my creation please can you add mine in this vote?

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

[Orenji_Reiji]

This theme is only for voting. Not for works. Also, no works will be now added. 5 days were more then enough to make 2 cards.

[Lunaze]

I make it for 3 days ago but i think my friend send them to you already and sorry if this bother you then

[Magus TSS]

The scores for all my judgement of the legions is complete and edited in my original post and may added to the totals. You may also remove this post if it's deemed spam afterwards.

[T_RD Ellino]

I give everything a 10/10 because legions are cool now I like the art choises and the fact that everyone put so much thought in their cards is truly amazing ^__^

[Rank Up]

Magus TSS, thank you.

[Rank Up]

New Top:

I)  (+3) №33 (124)
II)  (-1) №9 (122)
III)  (+1) №30 (121)
IV)  (-2) №13 (115.5)
V) (-2) №12 (112)
VI)  (0) №23 (110)
VII) (0) №25 (108)
VIII) (0) №26 (102)
IX) (+2) №10 (100.5)
X) (0) №14 (100)  - failed last top x) 24th should not be there

All Scores

1) (69)
2) (50)
3) (68)
4) (54)
5) (61)
6) (99)
7) (82.5)
(55)
9) (122) - 2
10) (100.5) - 9
11) (67)
12) (112) - 5
13) (115.5) - 4
14) (100) - 10
15) (91.5)
16) (82.5)
17) (67.5)
18) (85)
19) (87)
20) (71.5)
21) (95)
22) (90)
23) (110) - 6
24) (99)
25) (108) - 7
26) (102) - 8
27) (51)
28) (97)
29) (46+?)
30) (121) - 3
31) (44)
32) (93)
33) (124) - 1
34) (85)
35) (93)
36) (38)

"?" means there should be more points, but someone didn't vote this legion yet, while voting others.

Russian forum - last vote was from Ice_Guardian; English forum - last vote was from Hideyoshi.

P.S Hideyoshi, pls vote 29th legion.

[Mickey]

Mickey shall join in the votes
Hmm, Mickey's voting criteria.
Art - 5 points
Skill - 4 points
Must Have Stuffs/Miscellenous - 1 point (Flavor text is always forgotten o.o)

Spoiler

No. 1 - Art (4) Skill (2) Msc (1) Hmm the art seems nice but doesn't fit a VG card much, looks more like a WS card The skill is nice and just wat Maguses do but well kinda boring...
Total: 7/10

No. 2 - Art (3) Skill (1) Msc (0.5) The girls look nice but what happen to the white wings? The second skill for the g3 vg is weird o.o and if Onafiel skill is active at vg, the legion's atk will hit crazy heights, cb2 would be a much more reasonable cost for healing a dmg. Where is my flavor text for Julia?
Total: 4.5/10

No. 3 - Art (1) Skill (1) Msc (0.5) The art is meh... and there is no sync between the two pics... Its a legion contest not a contest for 2 cards Hagakure first skill is (V)? How do u even activate that? Skill for the boss is rather boring... Hmm, pretty sure u don't say counterblast 2 in a skill text.
Total: 2.5/10

No. 4 - Art (0.5) Skill (1) Msc (1) The art for individual is really nice but what happen to combining them? Its legion -.-Skills have totally no linkage with what witch does...
Total: 2.5/10

No. 5 - Art (4) Skill (1) Msc (0) The art is good tgt but... if viewing the g3 alone, its kinda weird... U totally forgot about the legion skill... Where is my flavor text? and the skill box for g2 is too big.
Total: 5/10

No. 6 - Art (5) Skill (2) Msc (1) The art is perfect very well done^^. Hmm the skills are good but don't think that's wat genesis  witches do.
Total: 8/10

No. 7 - Art (3) Skill (2) Msc (1) SAO <3 hmm but kirito will look weird alone and u can barely see his face... Skills are fine but what happen to the paying of cost for Asuna?
Total: 6/10

No. 8 - Art (1) Skill (0) Msc (0) The art is disturbing, though looks nice but definitely not nova grappler... Skills are not nova-like and the wordings are bad... Where is my flavor text?
Total: 1/10

No. 9 - Art (5) Skill (2) Msc (0) The art is really nice^^ Well done skills are okay but boring... creativity Pretty sure it is not BT06/064 and not removing the illustrator name is bad...
Total: 7/10

No. 10 - Art (4) Skill (3) Msc (0.5) The art is good Hmm looks a bit weird though like they aren't standing on equal grounds. The skills is very nice, good creativity. Though it being kagero, its more of ur choice then ur opponent. Nidhogg skill should only be for R if not, the legion will have double skill O.o The name need some work too for the g3...
Total: 7.5/10

No. 11 - Art (5) Skill (1) Msc (0) The art is well done^^ great work. Hmm, wat happen to the legion skill? The flavor text is gone too and skill box for Olivia is too big
Total: 6/10

No. 12 - Art (5) Skill (3.5) Msc (1) The art is great The skills are very nice and original^^ Though, it would be perfect if the condition of legion is stated.
Total: 9.5/10

No. 13 - Art (5) Skill (3) Msc (0) The art is nice^^ The skill for amakusa fits more for Tachi though. The second skill for Yasha is nice but cb2 should be a more reasonable cost or the skill could be toned down to -20k on opp. The V doesn't mean VG but meant for VG circle...
Total: 8/10

No. 14 - Art (3) Skill (3) Msc (1) The art is good but need more work merging them and it looks more like GP units. Skills are good^^ Second skill for Key though is abit too costly, and a bit of wording problem.
Total: 7/10

No. 15 - Art (4) Skill (2) Msc (1) The art is good^^ but the g3 seems inferior to the g2 The second skill is interesting for Ashvattha but in overall, it is gives an idea of "that's it?" No synergy of its skill with Caudex.
Total: 7/10

No. 16 - Art (1) Skill (3) Msc (0) The art is nice for the dragon but poorly combined and the g3 is bad on its own. The skill is interesting but the skill for Hikyu has some wording problems. Flavor text is gone and Narukami is definitely red...
Total: 4/10

No. 17 - Art (4) Skill (2) Msc (1) Lol rip-off from ygo. But the art is good^^ need more linkages between the two pictures though. Hmm, 12k atkers normally don't have another skill and it doesn't include VG. There is no cost to be paid for Whelp second skill.
Total: 6/10

No. 18 - Art (0.5) Skill (3) Msc (0) Nice arts on their own but no effort in merging them. Skills are interesting but the second skill for Helena should include a cost. V doesn't stands for vg but vg circle.
Total: 3.5/10

No. 19 - Art (4) Skill (2) Msc (1) Good art, need more linkages between the two, looks plain. The skills are interesting but third skill for loadover is really over the load and second skill should last until your end phase.
Total: 7/10

No. 20 - Art (4) Skill (2) Msc (1) Nice art, Atropos looks small compared to Laxesis and kinda empty on the right side. Skills are interesting but scing 3 of any cards of different name is too good for the cost of cb1. Atropos though got a decent skill. She should have a third skill though.
Total: 7/10

No. 21 - Art (5) Skill (2) Msc (1) Superb Art The second skill for overlord is more naru-ish... The third skill doesn't really need a cost. If do, it should add 5k power instead of 3k. Meteor Flame skill should be more of when opp rg is put into drop via eff, ur vg can don't have to be a legion that way Or it could power +5k instead of 3k.
Total: 8/10

No. 22 - Art (3.5) Skill (3) Msc (1) Good Art need more linkages between the two and the background exceeded the cards? Interesting skills for both of them. Bad Moon Dragon second skill should lock only 1 unit instead of all, its too OP if its all.
Total: 7.5/10

No. 23 - Art (4.5) Skill (2) Msc (1) Art is great, would be so much better if their eyes are on the same level. The skill for Custard is weird... Pie second skill is abit too good for the cost, maybe adding a sb1 would be better.
Total: 7.5/10

No. 24 - Art (4) Skill (3) Msc (1) The art is nice Gundams ftw! well too bad they look kinda bad alone. The skill is interesting^^ Cost is slightly high for reactive Kaiser though, cb2 should be good. For Booster Crasher, pretty sure it should state choose up to 2 of ur vanguard instead of using units on V.
Total: 8/10

No. 25 - Art (5) Skill (2) Msc (1) Art is Superb Rune skill should be for u to choose Morgana skill isn't really witch style...
Total: 8/10

No. 26 - Art (4.5) Skill (2) Msc (1) Art is great would be better if they interact more. SB1 skills are too Op for both Raku and Nagamitsu. Need to rethink about their costs.
Total: 7.5/10

No. 27 - Art (1) Skill (2) Msc (0.5) Art is good individually, no effort in merging... Skill is too op for Blond for being no cost. And not dropping hand for restanding vg is very bad... Pretty sure that isn't the symbol for legion
Total: 3.5/10

No. 28 - Art (4) Skill (4) Msc (1) Art is great Looks weird though when put tgt. The skills are really nice and interesting^^.
Total: 9/10

No. 29 - Art (5) Skill (1) Msc (0) Art is Fantastic where is the legion skill? Wording problems everywhere too. Flavor text is missing and skill box for spiral dragon is too big.
Total: 6/10

No. 30 - Art (5) Skill (2) Msc (1) Art is Wowza Divine fox skill is too OP for costless... Bladed Leopard 3rd skill lacks the word "paying the cost". Whats a g3+ vanguard?
Total: 8/10

No. 31 - Art (0) Skill (2) Msc (0) Art is bad, very bad... Rochster skill should only be at ur turn only? ERRANTE second skill should be act. You don't write Soul Blast 2 in skill text... The mate is always on the left side...
Total: 2/10

No. 32 - Art (4) Skill (3) Msc (1) Art is good^^ Need more interaction between the two though... Siolone skill is too GP-liked. Faun skills are really interesting^^. The third skill is abit too OP though.
Total: 8/10

No. 33 - Art (5) Skill (3.5) Msc (1) Art is Top-notched Senpuuhime skill is abit too op for sb1 though. CB1 and it would be perfect. Skills are interesting^^ though simple but new.
Total: 9.5/10

No. 34 - Art (4.5) Skill (2.5) Msc (1) Art is great. Love the eye contact they make   Gabrielle should be more zoomed in though... Selena second skill is abit too OP. Maybe adding sb 1 would be good. Gabrielle shouldn't need a cost.
Total: 8.5/10

No. 35 - Art (5) Skill (3.5) Msc (1) Art is lovely Hellhound skill is abit too OP. Maybe on the turn ur vg legion would be good. The Cost for legion is gone apparently o.o Skills are unique and interesting though
Total: 9.5/10

No. 36 - Art (0) Skill (2) Msc (1) Art is stupid... Skills are good but boring...
Total: 3/10

That's all from Mickey

Yours only,
Mickey

[Rank Up]

Fresh top:

I) (^_^) №33 (173)
II) (^_^) №9 и (+1) №30 (172)
III) -
IV) (^_^) №13 (160.5)
V) (+1) №23 (157.5)
VI) (-1) №12 (155.5)
VII) (+1) №26 (149.5)
VIII) (-1) №25 (145+?)
IX) (+2) №6 (145)
X) (-1) №10 (144)

All Scores

1) (98)
2) (65.5)
3) (86)
4) (65.5)
5) (82+?)
6) (145) - 9
7) (117)
(80)
9) (172) - 2-3
10) (144) - 10
11) (94)
12) (155.5) - 6
13) (160.5) - 4
14) (134)
15) (131)
16) (111.5)
17) (95)
18) (101.5)
19) (124)
20) (105)
21) (135)
22) (133.5)
23) (157.5) - 5
24) (143)
25) (145+?) - 8
26) (149.5) - 7
27) (65)
28) (136)
29) (77+?)
30) (172) - 2-3
31) (55)
32) (129)
33) (173) - 1
34) (119.5)
35) (131)
36) (47)

"?" means there should be more points, but someone didnt voted this legion yet, while voting others.

Russian forum - last vote was from Expy; English forum - last vote was from Mickey.

P.S. Hideyoshi, pls vote 29th legion.

[Orenji_Reiji]

No votes can be sumbitted now. The winners will be declared soon.

[Orenji_Reiji]

The votes were counted. Final scores are...:

Final Scores

1) (114) > ki,ee21 [eng]
2) (78.5) > Tym Kyzo [ru]
3) (94) > Szch [eng]
4) (77.5) > Sandy [eng]
5) (96) > Patrickzzz [eng]
6) (167) > Hichigo [ru]
7) (133) > lucius [eng]
(102) > metalikano [ru]
9) (202) > Ryukkun [eng]
10) (175) > -shockwave- [ru]
11) (111) > Patrickzzz [eng]
12) (185.5) > Raikou [eng]
13) (190.5) > Valek99 [ru]
14) (158) > Stacey [ru]
15) (166) > -shockwave- [ru]
16) (135.5) > metalikano [ru]
17) (120) > TheReniassanceMan [eng]
18) (118) > Chrysanta [eng]
19) (151) > [MK Hunter] E.T [eng]
20) (129) > Hichigo [ru]
21) (162) > Ryukkun [eng]
22) (161.5) > PalaNG [ru]
23) (186.5) > UnknownKIRA [eng]
24) (174) > Stacey [ru]
25) (184) > Ryukkun [eng]
26) (179.5) > Valek99 [ru]
27) (77) > JackJunk [eng]
28) (160.5) > Raikou [eng]
29) (91) > Patrickzzz [eng]
30) (206) > -shockwave- [ru]
31) (65) > Szch [eng]
32) (145) > Expy [ru]
33) (204) > UnknownKIRA [eng]
34) (146.5) > MaX [eng]
35) (157) > Raikou [eng]
36) (55) > Schz [eng]

And the winners are...

...drums on...

FIRST PLACE: critical kawaii of narure. Entry №30. Author: -shockwave-[ru]
SECOND PLACE: odd-eyed geishas. Entry №33. Author: UnknownKIRA[en]
THIRD PLACE: ninjas of bluis flames. Entry №9. Author: Ryukkun[en]

Thanks everyone for participating. The winners. Please, contact me, or even better Rem and tell your ingame nickname. You will be given with any sleeve from folder with sleeves.

[Rem]

Distributed to cover everything except Ryukkun. Write to the PM, nickname and number cover that you want.

[Ryukkun]

pm sent, just in case.
IGN: [T.CC]Ryukkun
Sleeve: #30 (Mameshiba)