1
Creative Works / Re: Contest: Mats in the Sky [Voting]
« on: October 17, 2015, 11:11:38 PM »
Well, I don't consider myself an expert in the making of mats, but... Opinions time!
Spoiler
Seventh Place
Mat #14
Honestly, just voting for this one to fill out the required 7. It certainly doesn't look horrible, but the rear-guard circles and zones are covered up and don't have the best choice of colours. The image choices just seem... A bit lazy.
Final Score: 5/10
Sixth Place
Mat #23
I really really want to like this mat more... But I can't. It's well done, but it just falls short compared to quite a few others that I feel were just done better which lowers its score.
Final Score: 6/10
Fifth Place
Mat #18
A well done mat but another that's mostly here to fill out the 7.
Final Score: 7/10
Fourth Place
Mat #11
I think this mat was rather cleverly made. It would've been nice to see the silhouette of Perfect Zygarde or whatever the form is called in the background of the middle just to complete everything, but it's still very well done. The circles look crisp and I really like the use of dual-colouring for the Vanguard circle.
Final Score: 7/10
Third Place
Mat #29
This almost looks like a mat Bushi would've officially made. It has everything but the trigger zone, and just looks very well done.
Final Score: 8.5/10
Second Place
Mat #16
I really really like this mat, and admittedly, it's better done than the one that has first place. Everything lines up to the other side, it looks like a single mat and not two stuck together, the background looks amazing, and the images chosen look like they're meant to be there, and aren't deformed at all.
Final Score: 10/10
First Place
Drumroll please...
Mat #14
Honestly, just voting for this one to fill out the required 7. It certainly doesn't look horrible, but the rear-guard circles and zones are covered up and don't have the best choice of colours. The image choices just seem... A bit lazy.
Final Score: 5/10
Sixth Place
Mat #23
I really really want to like this mat more... But I can't. It's well done, but it just falls short compared to quite a few others that I feel were just done better which lowers its score.
Final Score: 6/10
Fifth Place
Mat #18
A well done mat but another that's mostly here to fill out the 7.
Final Score: 7/10
Fourth Place
Mat #11
I think this mat was rather cleverly made. It would've been nice to see the silhouette of Perfect Zygarde or whatever the form is called in the background of the middle just to complete everything, but it's still very well done. The circles look crisp and I really like the use of dual-colouring for the Vanguard circle.
Final Score: 7/10
Third Place
Mat #29
This almost looks like a mat Bushi would've officially made. It has everything but the trigger zone, and just looks very well done.
Final Score: 8.5/10
Second Place
Mat #16
I really really like this mat, and admittedly, it's better done than the one that has first place. Everything lines up to the other side, it looks like a single mat and not two stuck together, the background looks amazing, and the images chosen look like they're meant to be there, and aren't deformed at all.
Final Score: 10/10
Spoiler
First Place
Drumroll please...
Spoiler
Mat #26
It's my favorite moment of the anime as a mat. That's why it gets first place over Mat #16. Again, its well made, and makes sense. The purple aura on the opposing side looks really good, and the way Leon is in front of the circles while their ace units are behind them just really looks awesome to me.
Final Score: 10/10
It's my favorite moment of the anime as a mat. That's why it gets first place over Mat #16. Again, its well made, and makes sense. The purple aura on the opposing side looks really good, and the way Leon is in front of the circles while their ace units are behind them just really looks awesome to me.
Final Score: 10/10